CNN analyst says ‘large drawback’ if Trump didn’t signal deportation orders

CNN political analyst Elie Honig is questioning President Trump over his latest deflection on how the 1798 Alien Enemies Act was invoked by the administration to hurry up the deportation of Venezuelan migrants allegedly linked to gang exercise.

Trump, chatting with reporters on Friday, instructed that “different individuals” dealt with the proclamation, pointing to Secretary of State Marco Rubio. He added that Rubio “has achieved an incredible job, and he wished them out and we go together with that … We need to get criminals out of our nation.”

Requested by CNN’s Kaitlan Collins what he believes the president was referring to, Honig dismissed the White Home’s argument that he was referring to the unique regulation.

“Was he telling us that, ‘I’m not John Adams, the man who signed it again in 1798?’ … The plain factor he was saying right here is, “I didn’t signal this proclamation that was used final week to deport these aliens,” Honig mentioned Friday on CNN’s “The Supply.”

“If that’s true, if Donald Trump didn’t really signal that proclamation, it’s a giant drawback as a result of the regulation particularly requires a proclamation by the president,” he added.

The 4-page proclamation does seem to have Trump’s signature, in accordance to a duplicate filed within the Federal Register.

Honig’s critique comes because the Trump administration is entrenched in a authorized battle over whether or not the latest deportation flights are authorized underneath the 18th century regulation. U.S. District Decide James Boasberg sought to dam the president from invoking the regulation, however the flights to El Salvador of migrants accused of being a part of the Tren de Aragua gang continued.

The federal decide lashed out on the administration for violating his order and requested the planes to be rotated. Officers argued that for the reason that flights have been exterior of U.S. airways when the directive was made, Boasberg had no proper to intervene. Trump later known as for his impeachment.

On Friday, the decide vowed “to get to the underside” of the difficulty, after the Justice Division resisted his calls for for extra info in regards to the flights, citing nationwide safety issues and accusing him of encroaching on the chief department’s authority.

Honig seemingly agreed with the decide, citing “a few flaws” within the administration’s argument for invoking the regulation.

“Initially, there needs to be an invasion, and it needs to be by a overseas authorities,” Honig mentioned. “And Donald Trump, in case you have a look at the proclamation, which perhaps he did or didn’t signal, tries to form of put collectively a really stretched argument that, ‘Sure, this was an invasion, sure, it was in some way tied with the Authorities of Venezuela.’”

He acknowledged that whereas most individuals are not looking for violent criminals within the nation, these within the U.S. illegally may very well be deported underneath regular statutes.

“However as a substitute, they’re utilizing this 1798 regulation, they’re stretching the definitions past all perception,” he continued. “And that’s why the decide, Boasberg, as we speak, expressed skepticism.”

Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This materials will not be revealed, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

For the newest information, climate, sports activities, and streaming video, head to The Hill.