Why it might make sense: On the mix, Steelers normal supervisor Omar Khan stated all choices could be “on the desk” to handle the QB state of affairs. Properly, the market now seems like a picked-over buffet stuffed with stale leftovers, particularly after Justin Fields and Sam Darnold signed elsewhere.
Contemplating the circumstances, Rodgers could also be one of the best remaining possibility. The Steelers already tried the opposite main candidate for the gig, Russell Wilson, and that ended with an 0-5 collapse down the stretch and friction with offensive coordinator Arthur Smith. The hope could be that in a extra steady setting, with the NFL’s highest-paid protection, a remade offensive line and a dedication to operating the ball, Rodgers could be more practical than he was in New York.
Let’s all do not forget that Peyton Manning received a Tremendous Bowl with a noodle arm, so there may be no less than a monitor document of an growing old veteran utilizing his thoughts and expertise to work round bodily limitations. That’s the wager the Steelers could be taking — whereas maintaining a tally of the 2026 draft class.
Why it wouldn’t make sense: Rodgers was a four-time NFL MVP and Tremendous Bowl champion and will probably be a possible first-ballot Corridor of Famer. However the Steelers must assume within the current tense: What’s he proper now, as a soon-to-be 42-year-old, simply 18 months faraway from a torn Achilles? The Jets came upon, as they failed to attain a landing in three video games final 12 months, together with two of the 11 video games Rodgers performed alongside his most well-liked goal, Davante Adams.
Past these apparent considerations, the scheme match is a curious one. In his prime, Rodgers used his mobility to increase performs and create outdoors of construction. Final 12 months, nonetheless, he appeared timid and unwilling to take photographs downfield. That doesn’t appear to mesh with the Steelers’ present roster development, which options DK Metcalf and George Pickens, who’re explosive deep threats however not the exact route runners Rodgers prefers.
Moreover, the Steelers have been making an attempt to return to their ground-and-pound roots with repeated investments within the offensive line. Solely three groups (the Eagles, Ravens and Lions) ran the ball extra final 12 months than Pittsburgh. How does a quarterback who tried the second-most passes within the NFL final 12 months match into that components?
Most significantly, the Steelers already twice believed that their extremely compensated protection might prop up an growing old quarterback — first with Ben Roethlisberger after his elbow harm and later with Wilson. Whereas Rodgers is a special model of passer, this might be thought of doing the identical factor and anticipating completely different outcomes.