Trump Says They’re Overseas Gang Members. Are They?

This transcript was created utilizing speech recognition software program. Whereas it has been reviewed by human transcribers, it could comprise errors. Please evaluate the episode audio earlier than quoting from this transcript and e mail transcripts@nytimes.com with any questions.

From “The New York Instances,” I’m Rachel Abrams. And that is “The Day by day.”

[MUSIC PLAYING]

In current weeks, the Trump Administration has deported a whole lot of Venezuelan migrants by rapidly labeling them as gang members and international enemies, boarding them on planes to El Salvador, and sidestepping their rights to a court docket listening to, the place anybody may be capable to scrutinize the claims made in opposition to them.

In consequence, little or no has been identified about who these males are or how they have been focused by immigration officers till now. Immediately, my colleague Julie Turkewitz explains who was truly on these planes, and the secretive course of that led to their deportations. It’s Wednesday, April 23.

So, Julie, as plenty of our listeners know, there’s been one story that has actually dominated the information cycle lately. It’s been the case of this man Kilmar Abrego Garcia He was the Salvadoran man who was on one of many planes that deported a whole lot of individuals from the US to El Salvador to those prisons. However you’ve been targeted on one thing else. You’ve targeted on the opposite 200-plus individuals who have been on these planes in addition to dozens of individuals across the nation who’ve been rounded up by immigration authorities. So are you able to simply inform us what particularly have you ever been attempting to look into?

Positive. Myself and a big group of reporters and researchers at The Instances actually needed to grasp who have been the individuals despatched to El Salvador, and the way they have been recognized. These are individuals who weren’t simply deported. They’ve additionally been incarcerated in another country, in a most safety jail constructed for terrorists.

And the Trump Administration has made every kind of claims about these people, saying that they’re members of this Venezuelan gang. However what we discovered, for instance, within the case of Abrego Garcia, is that what the federal government is saying in regards to the people that it’s sending to El Salvador for incarceration doesn’t at all times have plenty of proof behind it.

And so it was necessary to dig into who these persons are and if they’re, in reality, members of a gang, because the Trump Administration says they’re. As a result of if that’s not true, it opens up every kind of questions on who else might be recognized, with little or no proof as a member of a gang, and despatched to a jail in another country for a yr or years to return.

So that you talked about gang affiliations. That was one of many issues on the federal government’s agenda by way of why it focused these individuals. Are you able to simply discuss that a bit of bit extra? Remind us, what did the federal government say particularly in its accusations in opposition to a few of these individuals?

So proper across the time that the Trump Administration is sending these males to El Salvador, the Administration’s border czar Tom Homan comes out and says, these people are all members of the Tren de Aragua. Now, the Tren de Aragua is that this Venezuelan gang that has morphed right into a transnational felony group, however till lately was not likely thought of an enormous deal in the US.

After which earlier this yr, the Trump Administration declares the Tren de Aragua to be a international terrorist group that’s working with the Venezuelan authorities. And never solely that, however the Administration says that this gang, in collaboration with the Venezuelan authorities, is perpetrating an invasion of the US.

Wow.

Now, that is actually debatable, as a result of we don’t have proof that this group has arrived in the US in very massive numbers. And no matter connection they may have with the Venezuelan authorities just isn’t confirmed. However what the Trump Administration is doing is claiming that there’s an invasion in order that it may possibly invoke this 18th century regulation referred to as the Alien Enemies Act, that permits the Trump Administration to swiftly deport people who’re a part of a nation that has invaded the US or is at battle with the US.

Swiftly deport, that means like, no due course of, no time in court docket?

Right. Now the Supreme Courtroom, after the preliminary flights of 238 males went to El Salvador, mentioned that, no, going ahead, the Trump Administration should enable some form of due course of to those males. It should notify these males that they’re being focused, that they’ve been recognized as alien enemies, and it should enable them a possibility to combat that declare earlier than they’re deported.

After which on Friday, the Trump Administration tried to proceed to ship extra people to El Salvador utilizing the Alien Enemies Act. And the Supreme Courtroom weighed in once more and halted this effort and mentioned, no. At this level, this isn’t permitted.

And simply to be clear, one of many issues that the Supreme Courtroom appears to wish to protect right here is the appropriate of those males to defend themselves, perhaps say, hey, I’m not a gang member, current some proof for his or her protection, as a result of with out that, then we don’t know if errors are made. We don’t know if the Administration was appropriate within the proof it presents. And it looks like you truly have been the one digging into who these individuals have been. Inform us about what you truly discovered whenever you began to do this reporting.

To be very clear, the Trump Administration is being extraordinarily secretive about who has been despatched to El Salvador, and what proof it has in opposition to them. The US authorities and the Salvadoran authorities have refused to even launch a listing of who’s at present incarcerated in El Salvador. However my colleague Hamed Aleaziz was in a position to acquire the interior checklist.

These names have been initially reported by CBS. And we ran them via databases. So we have been doing background checks in Chile, in Colombia, in Peru. Now, I ought to word that it’s very tough to seek out felony data from everywhere in the world. There’s no worldwide public database that we may simply search and use to excavate info. So is it doable that we missed one thing? After all. However a group of us reporters and researchers devoted weeks to understanding the felony backgrounds of those people.

Proper.

And of the 238 males despatched to El Salvador, we have been solely capable of finding critical felony accusations or convictions for 32 of them.

What sort of critical crimes are we speaking about?

So, for instance, we discovered one individual with a homicide conviction in Venezuela. We discovered one other particular person who’s accused of kidnapping and drugging, and sexually assaulting a girl in Chile, somebody who authorities in Chile do consider is a member of Tren de Aragua. We discovered others who had been accused of being concerned in an assault in Chicago. And so we discovered some people with some fairly critical felony accusations or convictions.

So clearly, these are very violent offenses. Did you discover every other forms of felony exercise?

Completely. We discovered about two dozen individuals who had these a lot decrease stage offenses, rushing in a college zone, trespassing, driving with out correct registration. However the overwhelming majority of the individuals didn’t appear to have a felony document past generally infractions associated to their immigration circumstances.

So we’re speaking about felony data right here. However what in regards to the accusation that these males are in reality TDA or gang affiliated?

Effectively, that may be a good query, as a result of it’s necessary to level out that whereas in a minority, inside a handful of circumstances, for instance, this particular person in Chile, we did discover some proof that perhaps authorities consider their Tren de Aragua, for the overwhelming majority of those individuals, we discovered no proof that they’ve any connection to this violent Venezuelan gang.

However as we spoke to households of lots of the males on these planes, we began to seek out just a few frequent traits that seem to have led them to be targets for deportation. One one who I spent plenty of time talking along with his household is Arturo Suárez Arturo left Venezuela in 2016.

He had participated in anti-government protests in 2014, type of calling for change in Venezuela, and finally determined, due to the political state of affairs, due to the financial state of affairs, to maneuver to Colombia. Then he moved to Chile. In Chile, he meets his spouse, one other Venezuelan, a girl named Natalie.

[BEEPING]

Hiya.

[SPEAKING SPANISH]

I spoke with Natalie this month. She advised me a bit of bit about him.

[SPEAKING SPANISH]

He, in Chile, labored putting in these large-scale fridges. However his actual ardour and what individuals actually know him for, what his mates, his household know him for, is his music.

[MUSIC PLAYING]

And as part of his rising music profession, he had plenty of tattoos.

[SPEAKING SPANISH]

A few of them are aspirational, inspirational. One in all them is that this hummingbird on his neck. And one other is a phrase that his household describes as emblematic of his outlook. And it says, the long run is brilliant.

Cash is tight. And finally, Natalie will get pregnant. They usually determine that Arturo goes to go to the US. And the thought is that he’s going to go to the US, within the worst-case situation, I incomes {dollars} to help my rising household. Possibly my spouse comes to hitch me. Possibly I’m going again to Chile. Within the best-case situation, I meet every kind of fantastic producers and my profession actually takes off within the US, the place there’s actually simply a possibility to turn out to be like a world celebrity, versus Chile, the place you’re relegated to a a lot smaller stage.

So how does he finally get into the US?

So he enters the nation in September of 2024. He enters utilizing this utility referred to as CBP One That is this Biden-era utility that allowed individuals, and lots of Venezuelans took benefit of this, to current themselves on the US border and primarily ask for the chance to return in and make a case that they need to be capable to keep.

And truly, as soon as Arturo will get into the nation, he’s beginning to make some cash. And he and Natalie determine that finally he’s going to avoid wasting up, and he’s going to return to Chile. However he by no means will get the chance to make that journey again.

Why? What occurs?

So on February 8, he arrives at this home in Raleigh to movie a music video. And that’s the place he’s apprehended by immigration brokers.

[SPEAKING SPANISH]

In line with his household, immigration authorities inform him that he’s being detained on account of his immigration standing. He’s despatched to a detention heart in Georgia. He’s in a position to make cellphone calls. His spouse, Natalie, is in contact with him. However after a few month on this detention facility, Arturo tells his spouse —

[SPEAKING SPANISH]

— that he truly needs to be deported, that he’s able to have this nightmare be over, and that it’s method higher to be again in Venezuela or again in Chile than to be in a detention heart in the US. And so forth March 14, he calls her. And he tells her that he’ll in all probability be deported the following day.

[SPEAKING SPANISH]

I’ve been advised by American authorities that I’m being despatched again to Venezuela.

[SPEAKING SPANISH]

Natalie tells me that she’s simply so full of reduction. And he sends a textual content that evening, saying —

[SPEAKING SPANISH]

— I really like you. We’ll quickly be collectively endlessly. However after that message is shipped, a few day passes. And Arturo is silent. He primarily disappears. And Natalie begins to get actually nervous. And on March 16, when Arturo has not confirmed up in Venezuela, Natalie turns to Google.

And on her cellphone, she sorts into this little search field, deportations to Venezuela. And what pops up are these photographs of Venezuelan males deported and incarcerated in El Salvador.

And these are the photographs that I feel plenty of us noticed, with males with shaved heads, their arms behind their again, added some type of jail complicated, it seemed like.

Completely. She sees this photograph with this type of sea of males carrying these type of white jail outfits on the bottom, type of hunched over in a type of similar type. And —

[SPEAKING SPANISH]

She zooms in, sees the hummingbird tattoo, and realizes that one in every of them is her husband.

[MUSIC PLAYING]

We’ll be proper again.

So, Julie, earlier you mentioned that whenever you have been chatting with households of the lads on these planes, like Arturo’s, you started to note traits that they shared that appeared to have made them targets for deportation. Inform me about these traits.

So earlier this yr, the Division of Homeland Safety issued a inside guideline referred to as the Alien Enemy Validation Information. And this information provides us a window into how the Trump Administration is figuring out supposed members of the Tren de Aragua.

This information instructs officers to make use of a degree system to grade suspected members of the gang. As soon as somebody will get eight factors, they turn out to be a, quote, “validated member of the gang“, and, due to this fact, an alien enemy who could be topic to this sort of deportation. And, in fact, we all know that these people aren’t simply being deported, but additionally incarcerated.

Wait. OK, so a degree system, like if you happen to get sufficient factors, the federal government says you’re a gang member? Do I’ve that proper?

Right. That’s precisely the way it works.

Are you able to simply clarify that a bit of bit? Like, how are the factors truly assigned? And what do you accrue factors for?

So this doc instructs officers to provide people two factors if they’re found to have lived with a member of the Tren de Aragua, two factors for being photographed with a member of the group, two factors for utilizing social media to show symbols, unclear what these are, of the gang.

And most necessary, the doc instructs officers to provide 4 factors for having tattoos denoting membership within the Tren de Aragua, and one other 4 factors for displaying, quote, “costume identified to point allegiance to the gang.” And that form of costume contains high-end city streetwear. And it contains carrying sports activities gear from US sports activities groups with distinguished Venezuelans on them.

I imply, this strikes me as like, not foolproof. I imply, is that this level system that’s utilized by regulation enforcement, on this case, to establish gang members? Is that this typical, or is that this extraordinary? Can you set this into context for us?

So US regulation enforcement has used tattoos prior to now to establish members of a gang. And that’s as a result of there are some transnational gangs which have a presence in the US, like MS-13, that use tattoos as identifiers of membership. We’ve seen these type of huge MS-13 tattoos.

The issue is {that a} member of our group in Venezuela spoke with 5 totally different specialists on the Tren de Aragua. These are individuals who have been working with this group for years, police officers, lecturers, and a journalist who wrote a e-book in regards to the Tren de Aragua. And all of them say that Tren de Aragua doesn’t use tattoos as a marker of membership. And whereas there could also be many gang members who’ve tattoos, there are additionally many younger Venezuelan males who’ve tattoos.

Mm-hmm. And have been tattoos one of many frequent denominators you have been discovering amongst these males?

We spoke with households, and a few attorneys for 30 of the lads who have been despatched to El Salvador. And we discovered that no less than 27 of them have tattoos. And these tattoos embody names of members of the family, names of girlfriends and wives. They usually additionally embody issues like crowns, for instance, and inspirational messages.

And what we discovered is that despite the fact that the Tren de Aragua doesn’t use tattoos as a marker of membership, the federal government has a listing of tattoos that it considers to be suspicious, and that features, for instance, that crown tattoo that I discussed, that can also be sported by Lionel Messi, the well-known soccer star. It additionally contains the type of Michael Jordan Jumpman silhouette that, in fact, was popularized by Nike, and by the basketball star.

So the federal government seems to have taken this not likely very definitive standards, having tattoos or having crown and Jumpman tattoos, and mixing it with different not very definitive standards, like carrying city streetwear, and used it to establish somebody as a, quote, “validated member of this gang.”

Proper. As a result of presumably, there may be followers of Michael Jordan and Lionel Messi who need tattoos of photos that they helped to popularize. And people individuals may not be in gangs. And equally, individuals who put on city streetwear may not be in gangs. So it appears like from every thing you’ve gotten discovered, this technique of identification actually has some form of questionable flaws to it.

Completely. And the issue is that the doable misidentification of individuals as gang members has dire penalties. These males at the moment are in a jail. They haven’t had a court docket listening to. They’ve little or no entry to attorneys or their households.

And we all know that the situations on this jail that they’ve been despatched to are extraordinarily harsh. This jail was constructed by the president of El Salvador to be emblematic of his crackdown on horrible criminals in his personal nation.

The top of the Division of Homeland Safety, Kristi Noem, has mentioned that these people aren’t being held in the identical situations. However we don’t actually know that as a result of nobody has been given full and free entry to the jail. And these people, not like after they have been in US detention, now that they’re in Salvadoran jail, these people don’t have entry to a phone, or a messaging app, or a strategy to talk to the skin world what their lives are like on the within.

Do now we have any sense how lengthy they may be there?

When these males have been initially despatched to El Salvador, the president of El Salvador, Nayib Bukele, mentioned that they’d be imprisoned there for no less than a yr. And on the identical time, he referred to as that sentence, quote, unquote, “renewable.”

However what we’ve seen since is that Kristi Noem, the top of the Division of Homeland Safety, has come out and mentioned that she believes these people needs to be held within the jail for the remainder of their lives.

Julie, I really feel prefer it’s completely truthful for us to level out that these deportations may need been extraordinarily flawed, that these situations may be extraordinarily harsh. However I wish to word two issues. The primary is that many Individuals voted for President Trump and really feel that the immigration system on this nation is damaged. Even when some individuals enter this nation legally, they’re nonetheless, indirectly, benefiting from the nation to the detriment of Individuals.

And the second factor I wish to word is that it looks like we’re on this second proper now, the place individuals could be divided into two camps, simply to make a extremely broad generalization. In a single group, you’ve gotten people who find themselves alarmed by this lack of due course of, who say, pay attention, perhaps these guys ought to have been deported anyway, however we have to discover out by placing them via a system in order that we are able to make certain we’re not deporting the incorrect individuals, that everyone ought to have their day in court docket.

After which what we even have is one other group of those that really feel that it’s OK to have collateral harm, on this case, doubtlessly sending harmless males to a terrorist jail with a view to overhaul a damaged system. And I’m simply curious in case you are type of seeing the panorama in that method.

Yeah, I feel that’s completely a good abstract of the state of affairs. And I feel that it’s actually necessary to level out that what now we have seen within the final couple of months is a dramatic decline in individuals arriving on the US border. That is one thing that began below the Biden Administration due to a number of the stricter insurance policies that the Administration put in place, amongst different elements. Nevertheless it has actually been sustained, and has turn out to be very evident below the Trump Administration. The messaging that the Trump Administration is sending appears to have labored.

The factor is, we simply don’t understand how deep the collateral harm might be. We don’t know what persons are uncovered to on this jail in El Salvador. We don’t know in the event that they’ll get out ever. And what my colleagues and I are studying from new reporting prior to now few days is that there are extra people who find themselves now not displaying up on this public database of migrants detained within the US, however who aren’t on the interior authorities checklist of migrants despatched to El Salvador. Presumably, the US authorities is aware of the place they’re. However their households don’t know the place they’re. We don’t know the place they’re. They’ve primarily, for public functions, been disappeared.

Wow.

And I feel the priority of many individuals watching this play out is that the shift in coverage runs deeper than simply sending a few hundred individuals to a international jail.

[MUSIC PLAYING]

And so there’s this elementary query as as to whether what we’re seeing right here is the American individuals settle for that they’re keen to surrender sure rights with a view to sort out this drawback and really feel by some means safer in their very own nation.

Julie, thanks a lot.

Thanks.

We’ll be proper again.

[MUSIC PLAYING]

Right here’s what else you might want to know right now. Secretary of State Marco Rubio unveiled a plan to make main cuts to the State Division, calling the federal government’s diplomatic company, quote, “bloated, bureaucratic, and beholden to radical political ideology.”

The cuts deal with operations in Washington, however will even have an effect on the work of embassies and consulates abroad, together with the elimination of the Workplace of the Undersecretary for Civilian Safety, Democracy, and Human Rights, which is charged with advancing American values world wide.

And the manager producer of 60 Minutes, the Tiffany model of American tv journalism, resigned on Tuesday, saying that he was now not allowed to run the present the way in which that he at all times had and make unbiased choices. The producer, Invoice Owens, is barely the third individual to carry his place within the present’s 57 yr historical past. And his departure marked a brand new interval of turmoil for CBS Information and 60 Minutes, which is going through a $10 billion lawsuit from President Trump.

Immediately’s episode was produced by Carlos Prieto and Caitlin O’Keefe, with assist from Jessica Cheung and Will Reid. It was edited by Lizo Balen with assist from Maria Byrne and Michael Benoist, incorporates authentic music by Pat McCusker, Elisheba Ittoop, and Dan Powell, and was engineered by Chris Wooden. Our theme music is by Jim Brunberg and Ben Landsverk of Wonderly.

That’s it for The Day by day. I’m Rachel Abrams. See you tomorrow.